Sunday, June 30, 2019
Party: A Mystery – Book Review
Party: A Mystery
Written by Jamaica Kincaid
Illustrated b Ricardo Cortés
Published June 4, 2019
Why we chose this book:
T is entranced at present by mystery-solvers. He has not abandoned his love of monster-lore, but expanded it to include monster-mysteries, which, in turn, led us to mysteries. On top of it, we return again and again to Cortés's Sea Creatures from the Sky, so seeing his work again held great appeal. A review copy was provided by Akashic Books in exchange for an honest review.
Three girls are at a grown-up party, watching from the periphery and trying to figure out how to access the refreshments; two are friends and one is a younger sister. As older siblings are wont to do, the two exclude young Sue from their tete-a-tete. Sue's frustration, powerlessness, and disappointment are palpable as the girls witness but won't explain an unnamed something. Whatever it is, it is bilious. If you don't have a precise definition of bilious, prepare to look it up as we had to!
What I love best about Party is how seamlessly the illustrations and text meld. Cortés perfectly complements Kincaid's words. And together they convey the experience of a younger sibling so realistically that one must question whether this is fiction or non-fiction. The older girls not only have the self-satisfied look of those who relish having charge of a younger sibling (in a healthy, non-bullying way), but they sound like children who are trying on big words for size. And when the two older girls express disgust at how "bilious" what they observe is, I could feel my own stomach turn in reaction to their reaction. The expressions on the girls' faces are priceless!
Without spoiling the ending, I will say that it was the perfect capstone to Sue's party experience.
The illustrations and realism make Party a satisfying read that will resonate with younger siblings (or anyone who has experienced the frustration of ignorance). Two other aspects of Party enhance what is already a thoroughly satisfying book: the ending and the fact that the party is in celebration of Nancy Drew.
(Age: 4 years old)
Son: Let's start reading!
Mom: Are you excited? Why do you like mysteries?
Son: I am! 'Cuz they're spooky!
Mom: Where does it look like they are? That kinda reminds me of stairs in the museum.
Son: Probably they are at the museum.
Son: What does "querulous" mean?
(My first guess was wrong; my vocabulary is expanding with this book.)
Mom: Would you go up those stairs by yourself?
Son: No, 'cuz that would be too spooky.
Mom: Does this look like a grown-up party or a kid party?
Son: A grown-up party.
Mom: How do you feel? How does she look?
Son: Excited! Concerned!
Mom: What would you do if you didn't know what they were talking about?
Son: I would ask them.
Mom: That's a good plan. How does she [Sue] feel? What would you do if you were there?
Son: Sad. I would comfort her. I would hug Sue.
Son: What do you think they saw, Mom?
Mom: I don't know. They used two words to describe it: vile and bilious. What do you think they saw? A real thing or were they tricking Sue?
Son: Tricking her. To make her feel sad.
Mom: If the story kept going, what do you think the other girls will do? Do you think they will be nice to her?
Son: No, because they aren't nice. Maybe they'll write another story about those guys to tell us what happened.
Mom: This is a Nancy Drew book party. Would you want to go to a book party?
(We looked at my Nancy Drew books afterward.)
Son: Of course. Can you read me these?
Mom: When you are older.
An Interview with Author/Illustrator Mathew Franklin and Book Review of Frankie's Scared of Everything
An Interview with Author/Illustrator Mathew Franklin Author and Illustrator of Frankie's Scared of Everything Thank you to Mathew...
Book Review Monsters: A Magic Lens Hunt for Creatures of Myth, Legend, Fairy Tale and Fiction Written by Céline Potard Illustrated by S...
Written by Jonathan Hall Illustrated by Carol Ruzicka Published in 2012 Why we chose this book: At a very special story time at our...
Spotlight on Natural America I would love to meander through every state with T and his dad, taking in the natural treasures from t...